Private Gun Ownership - Good or Bad?

[peacetraveler22]

Last week, we had another mass shooting in America. A young college student deeply rooted in misogynist mentality, and frustrated by female rejection, decided to take a drive through a California college town and open fire, killing six people and wounding numerous others. As you know, guns are deeply rooted in American culture, and always have been. So why the recent proliferation of school and mass shootings over the last few years? I think in large part these tragedies are not a result of guns, but the sickness of society in general. After all, Americans have always been armed but the proliferation of mass shootings has been rather recent. Twenty years ago, or even ten, we didn't hear about such tragedies on a consistent basis.

People sometimes forget that the right to bear arms is expressly enumerated in the Second Amendment of the U.S. Constitution. Private gun ownership is a principle upon which my country was founded. We are the most heavily armed civilian population in the world, with close to 300 million firearms in the hands of civilians, including my family members. I am completely pro gun, and have always been surrounded by firearms. I shoot Rifles, a 9mm glock and .357 Magnum Revolver at the range under the supervision of my father. So, where is the delicate balance between respecting the Constitutional rights of U.S. citizens and preventing mass shootings?

I can't say there are any easy answers, nor do I know the best solution. For instance, in the most recent shooting, the culprit had a long history of mental illness. Police officers had even visited his house after worried calls from State mental health officials. Yet when they arrived, the shooter was completely calm and convincing. Thus, they had no legal grounds upon which to enter the home and search. If they had entered his room, they would have found his guns, his detailed plans for the massacre which he had been cooking for over a year, and other clear signs that something sinister was brewing.

People all over the globe are suffering from depression and other forms of mental illness, and they should not be under constant suspicion for seeking treatment. One simple way to mitigate widespread gun violence is to have tighter and consistent controls. Currently, gun laws drastically vary from State to State, and I don't claim to be an expert in nationwide legislation. Such knowledge is almost impossible. California is known as the strictest State, and Texas and my home State of Virginia are considered two of the most pro-gun locations in the nation. This is not surprising given that the National Rifle Association is headquartered only a 1/2 hour from my apartment. In Virginia, private citizens can openly carry firearms and I've seen it in restaurants, particularly in rural areas. Is it necessary? I don't think so. Only Washington, DC and Hawaii require all firearms to be registered.

Our founding Fathers made certain that private gun ownership will never completely become extinct in America, but this doesn't mean that laws shouldn't be changed. Some of the most strongly advocated solutions include:

(1) Background checks for all firearm owners
(2) Waiting period
(3) Registration of ALL firearms in every State
(4) For schools - allow teachers to carry firearms into the classroom and train them on use

What do you think? Do you wish Russia had more lenient laws for private gun ownership? What should America do to prevent these tragedies? I sometimes wonder if it's really possible to truly prevent a deranged person from committing these acts of violence. Even if tighter gun controls exist, they would likely still be able to obtain firearms on the black market. In the end, we cannot mandate good and evil, though an attempt should at least be made to control evil to the greatest extent possible.

Comments

[Алексей Петренко (from livejournal.com)]

I'm new to the States and all these dances around gun control make me understand that there are idiots in US politics as well as in Russian. Ok, there is no politics in Russia but anyway :)

The stories when the bill introduced in NY to decrease the size of the magazines from 10 to 7 rounds and explanation is mass shootings in schools... WHAT?! 8-0
The real explanation is the same as I saw many times in Russia: We did something loud. It does not and even can not have any effect on the problem in question. But this is a simple thing to do and we will shout everywhere that it does help. And some people will believe.

One of the effects of Santa Barbara shooting is the new bill proposed in California (less then a week from shooting) proposing a right for courts and polices to search and confiscate your guns if someone will tell the police that you're thinking about something bad.
It's even better then Minority report! :)

One important thing to remember is that all the gun control laws are affecting only law-abiding people. They do not have any effect on criminals.

[onkel-hans.livejournal.com]

Guns for the people cannot may not ever be allowed in Russia.

Government is perceived in the U.S, as an unfriendly agency. The Constitution,by definition, is a tool to protect the people against government.
The guns are available to the citizens of America because of their right to protect themselves against the government, primarily.

Exactly for the same reason it is inconceivable that the government may allow guns in Russia. There is no reason even to talk about this in Russia. First - get rid of your terrorist government. But - just you try!

[peacetraveler22.livejournal.com]

"proposing a right for courts and police to search and confiscate your guns if someone will tell the police that you're thinking about something bad..." I haven't read about this proposal, but of course it's ludicrous. Because such determinations about "bad thoughts" are subjective. Just like the crazy Russian law which passed last year where "insulting" religious feelings is punishable. Who determines which statements or actions are "insulting?" Why did you come to the U.S, for work or study? Welcome! :)

[Алексей Петренко (from livejournal.com)]

Here is the link with more info on this California bill: https://www.firearmspolicy.org/act/california/ab1014/

And yes, I'm here for work. Computers and all these things...
Thanks for welcoming :)

[peacetraveler22.livejournal.com]

Hope you have a smooth adjustment to life in America! Many differences in Russian and American cultures. :)